Very Tough Equation to Balance

Chemistry and homework help forum.

Organic Chemistry, Analytical Chemistry, Biochemistry, Physical Chemistry, Computational Chemistry, Theoretical Chemistry, High School Chemistry, Colledge Chemistry and University Chemistry Forum.

Share your chemistry ideas, discuss chemical problems, ask for help with scientific chemistry questions, inspire others by your chemistry vision!

Please feel free to start a scientific chemistry discussion here!

Discuss chemistry homework problems with experts!

Ask for help with chemical questions and help others with your chemistry knowledge!

Moderators: Xen, expert, ChenBeier

Post Reply
Visc
Newbie
Newbie
Posts: 1
Joined: Wed Jun 03, 2009 8:22 pm

Very Tough Equation to Balance

Post by Visc »

NH4ClO4 + Al = HCl + Cl2 + NO + Al2O3 + HOH

If anyone could give me some help and maybe try and explain it a little bit I would be very appreciative.
expert
Distinguished Member
Distinguished Member
Posts: 1623
Joined: Sun Feb 22, 2009 8:08 pm

Post by expert »

First try to figure out how particular atoms reduce/oxidize. Make the following analysis
NH4ClO4 + Al = HCl + Cl2 + NO + Al2O3 + HOH

2N(3-) - 10e- --> 2N(2+) – I doubled the nitrogen to make equal to total Cl – coming from the same molecule NH4ClO4
Cl(7+) + 7e- --> Cl(0)
Cl(7+) + 8e- --> Cl(1-)
Al(0) - 3e- --> Al(3+)

Basically, the complexity of this reaction is related to an unusual situation: it features two reducing agents and only one oxidizer. Still, the number of electrons given and accepted must stay equal. This provides a clue about basic coefficients. The total number of donated electrons is 10+3=13, and 7+8=15 accepted. The only coefficient can equalize them is 13x15=195. Nitrogen and Al must supply these electrons proportionally to their 10e- and 3e- loss, so let’s distribute these 195 electrons proportionally to demand by assigning multiplication coefficients:
2N(3-) - 10e- --> 2N(2+) x15 = 150e- = donated
Cl(7+) + 7e- --> Cl(0) x13=91e- - accepted
Cl(7+) + 8e- --> Cl(1-) x13=104e- accepted
Al(0) - 3e- --> Al(3+) x15=45e- - donated

Check: the number of donated and accepted electrons is equal and equal to the total of 195
The problem is that such coefficients will not provide equal numbers of N and Cl atoms – remember coming from the same molecule. We can only vary amount of Al.
Let’s equalize coefficients at N and Cl and let's absorb the difference by Al
2N(3-) - 10e- --> 2N(2+) x15 = 150e- = donated
Cl(7+) + 7e- --> Cl(0) x15=105e- - accepted
Cl(7+) + 8e- --> Cl(1-) x15=120e- accepted (total accepted 105+120=225; 225-150=75e- go to Al
Al(0) - 3e- --> Al(3+) x25=75e- - donated
Check again: the number of donated and accepted electrons is equal and equal to the total of 225
Now let’s put these found coefficients to play:
15x2NH4ClO4 + 25Al = 15HCl + 15/2Cl2 + 30NO + 25/2Al2O3 + #HOH
Let’s multiply by 2 for convenience and calculate the number of protons to make water:
60NH4ClO4 + 50Al = 30HCl + 15Cl2 + 60NO + 25Al2O3 + 105HOH

Finally oxygen check: 240 on the left and 240 on the right

Wow! That was the toughest one on this forum so far! Go collect your credit. I wonder where did you get this one?

By the way, this reaction has infinite number of solutions. That's why automatic program tells the following "Error: equation NH4ClO4+Al=HCl+Cl2+NO+Al2O3+HOH can be balanced in an infinite number of ways: this is a combination of two different reactions"http://www.webqc.org/balance.php
Remember safety first! Check MSDS and consult with professionals before performing risky experiments.
Post Reply